• Re: sending mail failing e-mail validation

    From Phil Taylor@1:275/201 to Robert Wolfe on Sat Jun 4 01:06:40 2022
    On 16 May 2022, Robert Wolfe said the following...

    On 11 May 2022, g00r00 said the following...

    I have tried every settings even using Mystic Mail server with u and password with no login information and it keeps failing to s the e-mail validation info.

    Okay thanks for providing your setup. It looks like you're setting Mystic up to connect to its own SMTP server.

    In order for e-mail to be sent out you have to have access to an external SMTP server from a mail provider, so Mystic can send mail to it. Most people used to use Gmail but I am not sure if Google still allows it for free.

    Yeah, I actually run my own outbound SMTP server which then connects to
    a third party SMTP delivery provider which happens to be SMTP2GO. You might want to look into signing up with them as I believe they have a
    free use option.

    ... That's not a bug, it's an undocumented feature

    --- Mystic BBS v1.12 A47 2021/12/25 (Windows/64)
    * Origin: Powered By Windows Server 2022 (1:116/17)


    I have everything setup by the docs and could be the issue? Is python used to call the validation script file or how does it work please? I am trying to figure out why it's not working when I tried every possible combination talked about this echo.

    Thanks
    Phil

    --- Mystic BBS v1.12 A47 2021/12/25 (Windows/32)
    * Origin: Mysticbbs.dynu.net:2025 (1:275/201)
  • From Nicola Mettimano@2:335/601 to All on Fri Sep 9 17:35:06 2022
    Hello guys, i found this discussion on google group beacause i have same problem.... @Robert Wolfe @Jay Harris
    I am going crazy but i can't i can't get it to work, i tried all, with and without LTS, plain, login but nothing.
    Strange thing is that linux logs don't write anything about using the sendmail command, it's like mystic doesn't use it so I can't see what the problem is; just mystic error.log write a minimal "Could not connect to SMTP server".
    I use my domain's SMTP standard server, i already configured my evolution client with same data and it work fine to send trought this SMTP but mystic nothing...
    Please help me :-(

    --- Mystic BBS v1.12 A47 2021/12/24 (Linux/64)
    * Origin: REtrogaming ACTivities (REACT) BBS (2:335/601)
  • From Nicola Mettimano@2:335/601 to all on Sat Sep 10 15:41:40 2022
    Some step forward here....
    Mystic use its code to send email trought an external SMTP, so is't not an OS/sendmail misconfiguration problem and then I was able to completely remove sendmail* from my OS.
    On my firewall (in real time filter) I saw that requests on ports 587 and 465 are sent to theexternal SMTP server so the problem was certainly authentication. I switched SSL/TLS from yes to no and changed port to standard 25 and it worked, then the problem is cryptlib related, i think; i use 3.4.5.0 compilend under Ubuntu server 22.04 and g++ 9 (is't the only way to compile it under my os).
    g00r00 what do you think about?

    --- Mystic BBS v1.12 A47 2021/12/24 (Linux/64)
    * Origin: REtrogaming ACTivities (REACT) BBS (2:335/601)
  • From Robert Wolfe@1:116/18.1 to Nicola Mettimano on Tue Sep 13 08:21:38 2022
    Hello guys, i found this discussion on google group beacause i have same problem.... @Robert Wolfe @Jay Harris
    I am going crazy but i can't i can't get it to work, i tried all, with and without LTS, plain, login but nothing.
    Strange thing is that linux logs don't write anything about using the sendmail
    command, it's like mystic doesn't use it so I can't see what the problem is; just mystic error.log write a minimal "Could not connect to SMTP server".
    I use my domain's SMTP standard server, i already configured my evolution client with same data and it work fine to send trought this SMTP but mystic nothing...

    Doesn't Mystic have it's own SMTP daemon built into MIS?
    --- Platinum Xpress/Win/WINServer v7.0
    * Origin: Spectrum BBS * spectrum.winserver.org (1:116/18.1)
  • From Nicola Mettimano@2:335/601 to Robert Wolfe on Tue Sep 13 15:31:42 2022
    Doesn't Mystic have it's own SMTP daemon built into MIS?

    Yes, I discovered this by doing a lot of tests and interrogating my firewall. On Mystic wiki talk abount sendmail (generic) so I thought it was referring to my os's sendmail...
    Anyway problem solved; using google password for app it work
    Thanks to all, your advice is very useful ;-)

    --- Mystic BBS v1.12 A47 2021/12/24 (Linux/64)
    * Origin: REtrogaming ACTivities (REACT) BBS (2:335/601)